
It was very much a family outing to Wan Chai District Court yesterday, as two of Lily Chiang Lai Lei's five* sisters turned up to lend her their support. As for Lily herself, she appeared to have had another of those bouts of ill health to which she is prone every ten years, as she was sporting a face mask alongside her stylish new haircut.
What price, I wonder, that ultimate courtroom accessory, the wheelchair, next week, when, as the
Hong Kong Standard reports ominously, Judge Albert Wong Sung Hau will "pass sentence" after her legal team has presented mitigation submissions today?
Of course, coming up with a decent "mitigation submission" is likely to test the mettle of even the most creative lawyer, when his client is alleged to have pocketed more than HK$3.7 million though the simple expedient of instructing ten members of staff to hold shares on her behalf, wait for them to turn a profit and then transfer the money into accounts held by her.
"M'lud, she was generous in her charity work beyond the call of duty, giving away more than five percent of the money she purloined"?
I'm not sure that would cut it.
Someone asked me why this sort of fraud isn't perpetrated more frequently if it's so easy to carry out. As so often, the answer is to be found in the question. The law of averages suggests that if you involve ten people in a scam then one of them is going to start singing like a canary unless you look after them all very well. After all, most people will want a large slice of the pie if they smell the apples, raisins and cinnamon and if on top of that they see the master chef going in and out of the kitchen with bucket loads of flour.
An all-expenses paid trip to look after "business" in Taiwan, with unlimited shopping on the side, such as the Chinese press report was offered to her secretary, is hardly going to cut it, especially when intimidating types from the ICAC come knocking with a tempting offer of immunity seasoned with what Judge Wong calls pressure to give evidence that is
"difficult to resist".
Of course, the other problem with simple schemes is that they are correspondingly simple to detect and unmask. No dead-ends and no impenetrable paper trails mean no opportunity for the legal industry to generate labyrinthine legal arguments.
Little wonder, then, that one of Lily's sisters, Ann Chiang Lai Wan, vice-chairwoman of the Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong, told reporters that their father, millionaire industrialist Chiang Chen, was prepared for the worst in respect of the youngest** and "cleverest", as he used to be proud of calling her.
Meanwhile, in the parallel universe that is religious broadcasting, last night, as chance would have it, another sister, Agnes Chiang Lai Ping, a former singer/actress of no particular note, was appearing on Creation TV, Hong Kong’s answer to GOD TV. Agnes reminisced with her young daughter about a recent visit to the United States and in particular a mansion that had caught her daughter's imagination.
"Mummy, that house is soo big."
"Yes, darling, but wouldn't you prefer to have Jesus rather than that big house."
"I don’t know, mummy. I'd like both."
"But, if you could have only one, which would you choose?"
"Jesus, I think."
"Good, darling. Why?"
"Because he’d make me happy."
Out of the mouths of babes and sucklings … I hope Auntie Lily was listening.
* Lily is one of seven sisters according to the SCMP of 10 June 2011
** Lily is the fourth child according to the same source